The great Auckland property divide

by Alistair Helm in


As the topic of affordable housing continues to capture the headlines; the statement is so often made that Auckland is one of the least affordable places to live in the world. Now I don't propose to debate this question, outside of making the point that if house prices were unaffordable, as in truly unaffordable; then the demand would shrivel up and price expectation would adjust accordingly. Now I know this is a simplistic statement, and the fact is that property prices have more than doubled over the past decade pricing many out of the market. However the fact remains that every day 60 properties are bought and sold across Auckland at a median price of $835,000. By comparison I see that the average advertised price for all property in Great London is now NZ$1,169,000 and in Sydney the sale median price is now NZ$1,225,000. The common link is that all 3 cities are centres of innovation and economic growth and are the leading city of their respective country. It is also not surprising that all three cities are simultaneously experiencing house prices falling, such is the connectedness of global property prices.

This current median price of Auckland property of $835,000 is 84% higher than the median property sales price outside of Auckland, where the latest median price is $455,000.

I was curious to see how this premium for Auckland property had tracked over the past couple of decades to see just how relatively unaffordable Auckland had become in domestic terms and thereby provide insight into the property price divide between Auckland and the rest of NZ.

I have chosen not to use median price as the metric for this analysis. As I have mentioned in preceding articles my favoured measure is the Stratified Price Index provided by the Real Estate Institute. This is in my opinion, the most accurate measure of house sales price for comparative purposes.

So this analysis is presented in the chart below, it is to my way of thinking quite enlightening. At this time based on the price index Auckland is trading at a 95% premium to rest of the country. Three years ago the divide between Auckland prices and the rest of NZ peaked at 128%, with Auckland more than double the price in the rest of the country.

The Auckland divide of house prices comparing Auckland with the rest of NZ

The historical perspective is very interesting. Back when data was first reported by the Real Estate Institute in 1992, property prices in Auckland were 40% above that of the rest of the country, through the mid 90's that shot up to 80% premium, a level that was pretty much sustained through until the end of 2013. Then began a surge in prices outside of Auckland, at a time when Auckland prices were certainly rising. This pushed the divide down to just under 50% at around the start of the GFC.

The next 7 years from 2008 Auckland went on a relative rollercoaster ride as compared to the rest of the country driving the divide from 50% up an ever accelerating steep curve to top out in 2015 at that level of 128%.

Given the current picture of property prices outside of Auckland compared to Auckland it is very likely that the divide will continue to fall in the coming year reducing the Auckland premium from 95% closer to 75% / 80%.